In a merchant cash advance vs business loan comparison, the loan wins on cost almost every time, and the business line of credit is the loan most owners should be comparing against, because it serves the same short, recurring cash needs an advance is sold for. A line of credit at even a high online rate cost about 44% less than a typical advance in our first example below. The advance wins on two things only: speed measured in hours, and approval when nothing else will approve you.
This page is part of our business loan comparison series. We arrange both products through funding partners who pay us at closing; you pay nothing. Because advances typically pay brokers more than lines do, we show every offer as an APR-equivalent with total dollars repaid, so the incentive is visible.
| Merchant cash advance (MCA) | Business line of credit | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A purchase of your future receipts at a discount; not legally a loan | Revolving credit; interest on the balance you carry |
| Amount | Sized to monthly card or bank receipts; one provider lists a $15,000 monthly revenue minimum | $10,000 to $150,000 at one large bank; up to $250,000 online; more if secured |
| Term | Repaid in 3 to 18 months typically (6 to 24 at some providers) by daily or weekly holdback of 10% to 20% of receipts | Revolving with annual review at banks; 6 to 24-month amortizing draws online |
| Cost range (illustrative) | Factor rate 1.1 to 1.5 (one provider advertises "as low as 1.11"); about 2.5% origination; APR-equivalent roughly 40% to 350% | Prime + 1.75% to prime + 9.75% at one bank (8.50% to 16.50% at 6.75% prime); one large online lender reports a 59.8% average APR; market range roughly 10% to 99% |
| Speed | Approval in about 2 hours; funding in about 4 hours to same day | Same day to 3 days online; 2 to 6 weeks at a bank |
| Qualification | FICO 500+, 6 months in business, $15,000 monthly revenue at one provider | FICO 625+, 12 months, $10,000 monthly revenue online; 680+ and 6 months at one bank |
| Best for | A genuine emergency when no loan will approve you and the payback is short | Recurring gaps: payroll timing, inventory, seasonal dips, slow-paying customers |
Amounts, rates and terms shown are illustrative examples, not an offer or a quote. Select Loan Advisors is not a lender; funding partners set all terms. See how we're compensated.
A merchant cash advance is priced with a factor rate, not an interest rate. A 1.3 factor on $50,000 means you repay $65,000 regardless of how fast you pay. The CFPB describes an MCA as "structured as a sale of potential future income" with a "payback" multiple such as 1.2 or 1.5. Because the payback is fixed and the daily draws start immediately, the annualized cost is far higher than the factor rate suggests.
A simple conversion: APR ≈ (factor rate − 1) × (365 ÷ days to repay). A 1.3 factor repaid over 6 months is 0.30 × 2.0, about 60%. The same 1.3 over 12 months is about 30%. Because payments are front-loaded, the true amortized APR is higher still. A business line of credit is quoted as an interest rate on a declining balance, so the number you see is closer to what you pay.
MCA at a 1.3 factor with a 2.5% origination fee:
Online line of credit at a 59.8% APR, $50,000 amortized over 6 months:
Bank line of credit at prime + 3.75% (10.50%), same schedule:
The online line wins by about $7,180, roughly 44% less than the advance, even at one of the highest average APRs disclosed by an online lender. The bank line wins by about $14,700, roughly 90% less. Same money, same six months.
A landscaping firm needs $30,000 three times a year, for about 60 days each, waiting on commercial customers.
Line of credit at 12.00%, drawn three times for 60 days:
Three advances of $30,000 at a 1.25 factor with 2.5% origination:
The line wins by about $22,800. This is the renewal trap: an advance is repriced from scratch every time you take one, while a line costs only for the days a balance is outstanding.
A restaurant, eight months in business, FICO 540, $20,000 a month in card receipts. A walk-in cooler fails and the repair is $15,000; without it the kitchen closes for two weeks. No line of credit will approve this file: lender-stated minimums start at FICO 625 and 12 months in business.
MCA at a 1.25 factor, 15% holdback of card receipts, 2.5% origination:
Doing nothing: two weeks closed at $20,000 a month is roughly $9,200 of lost revenue, plus spoiled inventory and staff you may lose.
Here the advance wins by about $5,000 against the alternative that actually exists. Two conditions make it the right call: the money produces revenue that repays it, and it is one advance, once. Take it, repay it, then build a file that qualifies for a line.
We check options with a soft credit pull, which the CFPB confirms does not affect your score. Every advance offer is shown next to any line or loan you qualify for, as an APR-equivalent with total dollars repaid, and we tell you when waiting is the better answer. See how business loan brokers work, how do business loan brokers get paid, and our business loan broker vs direct lender comparison.
Rarely on cost. In our $50,000 six-month example, an advance at a 1.3 factor cost about $16,250 against about $9,074 for an online line of credit and about $1,542 for a bank line. An advance is better only when no loan will approve you, the need is a one-time emergency that protects revenue, and you can repay it once without renewing.
It depends on the factor rate and how fast you repay. A simple approximation is (factor rate − 1) × (365 ÷ days to repay): a 1.3 factor over six months is about 60%, and over 12 months about 30%. Because daily payments are front-loaded, the true amortized APR is higher. Aggregator estimates put MCA APR-equivalents at roughly 40% to 350%.
Legally, usually not. The CFPB describes it as structured as a sale of a portion of future receipts, repaid through a holdback or fixed daily debits. That is why it is priced with a factor rate rather than an interest rate and why some consumer-style lending rules do not apply. It still has to be repaid, and personal guarantees are common.
Sometimes. Large online lenders list FICO minimums around 625 with 12 months in business and $10,000 in monthly revenue. Below that, a line is unlikely and the realistic options are an advance, invoice factoring if you have B2B customers, or waiting. If you are within 20 to 30 points of 625, a few months of card paydown is usually worth more than any product.
Because advances typically pay brokers a higher percentage than bank lines or term loans do, and they close in hours. That is the incentive to guard against. Ask any broker to show each offer as an APR-equivalent with total dollars repaid, and to name the products you do not qualify for. A broker who only talks in factor rates and daily payments is selling, not advising.
If you are looking at an advance offer today, send it to us before you sign. We will convert it to an APR-equivalent, check whether a line or loan is realistic for your file, and tell you plainly if the advance is, in fact, the right call.
Check My Options →